by Ayele Addis Ambelu : Ayeleradio@gmail.com

Low-income producers and consumers of food in Africa are more vulnerable to climate change, owing to their comparatively limited ability to invest in more adapted institutions and technologies under increasing climatic risks. Therefore, how we manage our food systems needs to be urgently changed if the goal is to achieve food security and sustainable development more quickly. This review paper analyzes the nexus of “climate-smart agriculture-food systems-sustainable development” to draw sound ways that could allow the rapid transformation of food systems in the context of climate change pressure. We followed an integrative review approach based on selected concrete example experiences from ground-implemented projects across Africa (Ghana, Senegal, Mali, Burkina Faso, West Africa, Ethiopia, Kenya, Rwanda, and Tanzania in East Africa). Mainly composed of examples from the Climate Change, Agriculture, and Food Security (CCAFS) Research Program of the CGIAR (former Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research) and its partners, these also included ground initiatives from non-CGIAR that could provide demonstrable conditions for a transformative agriculture and food systems.
The lessons learned from the ground implementation of climate-smart agriculture (CSA) in the African context were instrumental to informing the actions areas of the food-system transformation framework suggested in this paper (reroute, de-risk, reduce, and realign). Transforming Food Systems in Africa under Climate Change Pressure: Role of Climate-Smart Agriculture by Robert B. Zougmoré, Peter Läderach, and Bruce M. Campbell inform 24 initiatives across Africa, but with a focus on the following studies for in-depth analysis: (1) the climate-smart village approach to generate knowledge on climate-smart agriculture (CSA) technologies and practices for their scaling, (2) the use of climate information services (CIS) to better manage climate variability and extremes, and (3) the science–policy interfacing to mainstream CSA into agricultural development policies and plans.
Transforming Food Systems in Africa under Climate Change Pressure: Role of Climate-Smart Agriculture by Robert B. Zougmoré, Peter Läderach and Bruce M. Campbell analysis showed that CSA could contribute to driving a rapid change of food systems in Africa through (1) the implementation of relevant climate-smart technologies and practices to reroute farming and rural livelihoods to new climate-resilient and low-emission trajectories; (2) the development and application of weather and climate information services (WCIS) that support de-risking of livelihoods, farms, and value chains in the face of increasing vagaries of weather and extreme events; (3) the use of climate-smart options that minimize waste of all the natural resources used for growing, processing, packaging, transporting, and marketing food, and therefore mitigating the carbon footprint attached to this food loss and waste; and (4) the realignment of policies and finance that facilitate action in the four proposed action areas through the identification of new ways to mobilize sustainable finance and create innovative financial mechanisms and delivery channels.
The Food System Transformation Initiative,, led by CCAFS with more than a a hundred partners proposes a framework with four interlocking action areas for reconfigurations of food systems. The action areas include the following:
- Reroute farming and rural livelihoods to new trajectories;
- De-risk livelihoods, farms, and value chains,
- Reduce emissions through diets and value chains and
- Realign policies, finance, support to social movements, and innovation. In continuation, we highlight in more detail the essential actions required in the African context.
(i) Reroute farming and rural livelihoods to new trajectories that reduce emissions and are climate-resilient. Ensuring zero agricultural land expansion on high-carbon landscapes is a key component. Most agricultural expansion in carbon-rich landscapes, such as coffee/cocoa plantations, is driven by only a few market commodities and often due to low yield, such as, for example, cocoa production in West Africa. Schroth et al. explain how CSA practices can be targeted along a climate change impact gradient in the West African cocoa belt: In the case of little affected zones, practicing sustainable intensification is recommended. However, for moderately affected zones, diversification and agronomic adjustments of farming practices, such as targeted shade and soil management. Gradual crop changes will be required to utilize and restore severely affected zones. If soundly implemented, the above CSA practices can support the cocoa production system to become climate-smart. An example of how to enable markets and public sector actions to incentivize climate-resilient and low-emission practices comes from the Ethiopian Agricultural Transformation Agency (ATA). Over one million hectares of degraded land have been restored in Tigray, and the area irrigated has increased massively, enabling farmers to produce higher-value vegetables and fruits even in drought. This land restoration has induced significant vegetation cover through the growth of fruit trees, therefore contributing to creating low-carbon emission landscapes through increased carbon sequestration.(ii) De-risk livelihoods, farms, and value chains to deal with the increasing vagaries of weather and extreme events; secure, resilient livelihoods and value chains through early warning systems and adaptive safety nets are essential. CCAFS collaborated with the Senegalese National Meteorological Agency (ANACIM) to develop weather and climate information services (WCIS) that are relevant to farmers on a broad scale. As of August 2015, seasonal forecasts are transmitted nationwide through 102 rural community radio stations and SMS, potentially reaching 7.4 million rural people across Senegal. Climate information in Senegal is now considered an agricultural input, just like seeds, fertilizers, and equipment, which are at the basis of production. An impact assessment study revealed that using CIS in Senegal led to 10–25% increases in household income. Helping farmers make better choices by de-risking their farming activities has proven successful in East Africa (Kenya, Rwanda, and Tanzania), where the Agriculture and Climate Risk Enterprise (ACRE) recently scaled to reach nearly 200,000 farmers, bundling index insurance with agricultural credit and farm inputs. ACRE, a licensed insurance intermediary that provides risk management solutions to reduce agricultural and climate risks, has built on strong partnerships with regional initiatives such as M-PESA (M for mobile, pesa stands for money in Swahili) mobile banking. The insurance is designed so that farmers can insure their farm inputs against drought, excess rain,, and yield shortfall.
The insurance covers input loans provided to farmers by the agriculture service provider. The method allows insuring farms as small as one acre and larger farms by replacing costly farm visits with measurements from weather stations to approximate actual farm losses. By doing so, this agricultural micro-insurance scheme effectively reduces the impact of severe weather and supports increased farm productivity investment. Insured farmers can buy certified seeds and invest in fertilizer instead of planting kept seeds and forgoing investing in soil nutrients. Also, in the years following droughts, insured farmers can continue farming as they had before the drought. In contrast, their uninsured neighbors continue to feel the negative impact of the loss for many more seasons.Another example of CSA practice that helped de-risk farms and livelihoods is the Risk reduction, Risk transfer, Prudent Risk-taking, and Risk reserves (R4) initiative in Ethiopia and Senegal. Launched by the World Food Program and Oxfam, the program has scaled unsubsidized index insurance to over 20,000 poor smallholder farmers who were previously considered uninsurable, using insurance as an integral part of a comprehensive risk management portfolio. Moreover, the Index-Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI) project in Kenya and Ethiopia demonstrates innovative approaches to insuring poor nomadic pastoralists in challenging circumstances.(iii) Reduce emissions from diets and value chains, targeting health and climate outcomes. Reducing food loss and waste is central to the three pillars of CSA, to increase food security and resilience (CSA adaptation pillar), decrease emissions through wasting valuable agricultural products (CSA mitigation pillar), and increase the productivity of food systems (CSA productivity pillar). Examples from Sub-Saharan Africa show that reducing food loss can provide economic returns and reduce emissions. Indeed, through food loss and waste, there is a waste of all the natural resources used for growing, processing, packaging, transporting, and marketing food; therefore, a carbon footprint is attached to this food loss and waste. Approximately 10–20% of cereal production in Sub-Saharan Africa is lost post-harvest, resulting in decreased farmer income and food insecurity. Farmer investment in hermetically sealed cereal storage bags has greatly reduced cereal losses. The bags protect cereals and other crops from insect infestation and other potential damages, reducing post-harvest loss from an average of 14% to less than 1% and reducing emissions proportionally.
Producing the bags requires relatively low upfront costs, and farmers can recoup their investment in the bags within a single farming season. Another example could be the use by many farmers of some form of chemical or natural spray during home-based storage to keep pests and insects away from food, mitigating post-harvest losses. A review study by Sheahan and Barrett reported that the largest known promotion scheme of chemical protectants in storage is via Malawi’s input subsidy program, which subsidized maize storage chemicals between 2009 and 2012 alongside inorganic fertilizer and improved seed varieties. Farm-household level impacts include an increase in the probability of adopting improved maize varieties and increases in total area and share of area planted to improved maize.(iv) Realign policies, finance, support to social movements, and innovation to facilitate action in the above action areas. Unlock billions in sustainable finance is paramount in this. Financing the transformation to low-carbon and resilient global food systems will require much larger investments in climate-smart agriculture, specifically from domestic budgets and the private sector. To overcome this financing gap, it will be necessary to blend public and private finance to help achieve climate-smart agriculture objectives while meeting the risk-return profile of different investors. In addition, innovative financial mechanisms and delivery channels will need to be developed to ensure that smallholder farmers and agribusiness can access the capital they need to increase their productivity, build their resilience, and help reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
The West African Initiative for Climate-Smart Agriculture (WAICSA), led by the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), is a great example of how to promote CSA to build resilience among smallholder farmers. Climate-smart agriculture (CSA) can offer smallholders a way to absorb climate shocks better and sustainably increase productivity and income. However, unaffordable financial services coupled with a lack of information and the high upfront costs of implementing CSA practices limit the ability of smallholder farmers in West Africa to adopt CSA practices. WAICSA provides financial and technical support to incentivize the adoption of climate-smart agriculture and increase local financial institutions’ capacity for climate-smart lending. According to the Global Innovation Lab for Climate Finance, if brought to scale, WAICSAcano improve the food security of 90,000 smallholder farming households in the region and convert over 185,000 hectares to climate-smart agriculture. The fund can also contribute to mitigating up to 2 million tons of CO2 emissions annually, equivalent to over 4 billion miles of driving.
