Presented by Amhara Region Media and Art Charitable Association (ARMACA)
Supported by the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting

1. The River that Wrote a Continent

At dawn, Lake Tana glows like a bronze mirror. Fishermen in reed boats glide toward the mist, and in the distance, church bells echo across the water, a prayer to a river that has written the story of Africa for millennia.

It is here, at the source of the Blue Nile, that the question begins: Who owns the Nile?

Dr. Ayele Ambelu, the president of ARMACA, begins his live radio introduction with a familiar phrase — one that carries both pride and pain for Ethiopians:

“The Nile is not just water. It’s history, heritage, and hope. But it is also politics, power, and pressure.”

This episode, Legal and Institutional Currents, the first in ARMACA’s “Voices for Climate and Community Resilience” series, unfolds with the support of the Pulitzer Center. Inspired by Pulitzer’s award-winning story “Who Owns the Nile? Ethiopia’s War Against Itself”, the discussion brings together local voices and global experts to explore one of Africa’s most complex legal questions — how to share a river that sustains 250 million lives across eleven nations.

2. A Legacy of Laws and Injustice

“The 1929 and 1959 treaties between Egypt and Sudan were never agreements of the basin — they were colonial contracts of exclusion.”
Dr. Salman M.A. Salman, ARMACA Hydropower Webinar on Legal Frameworks, 2025

Dr. Salman’s voice came through the broadcast clear and firm, echoing decades of frustration shared by upstream nations like Ethiopia, Uganda, and Tanzania. He explained that while the Nile has always been a shared resource, its laws were built on a foundation of inequity.

In his view, “The colonial agreements were not about cooperation but control.”
These treaties granted Egypt near-total rights over the river and the power to veto any upstream development.

As listeners called in from Bahir Dar, Gonder, and Wollo, the sentiment was the same — “How could we be denied the right to use our own water?”

The ARMACA team, in collaboration with the Pulitzer Center, juxtaposed Dr. Salman’s insight with Pulitzer’s reporting from Cairo. In “Who Owns the Nile?”, journalist Ann Neumann wrote that Egyptians view Ethiopia’s Grand Renaissance Dam with deep suspicion, fearing it as “a slow-motion catastrophe.” Yet for Ethiopians, it represents a long-delayed right, the right to light their homes and power their future.

3. The Birth of the Nile Basin Initiative

To address this historical imbalance, the Nile Basin Initiative (NBI) was formed in 1999, a landmark attempt at cooperation.

“The NBI was a child of compromise,” explained Dr. Ana Elisa Cascão, a renowned scholar on water diplomacy, during the ARMACA webinar. “It was designed to move the basin from confrontation to cooperation.”

The NBI brought together all riparian states, from Burundi to Egypt, under a shared vision of “sustainable socio-economic development through equitable utilization.”

But as Dr. Cascão pointed out, the NBI remained a transitional body, not a binding institution.

“Without a permanent legal framework, cooperation risks becoming optional. That’s the heart of our problem.”

The legal vacuum remains; the long-debated Cooperative Framework Agreement (CFA), drafted in 2010, was never signed by Egypt or Sudan. This left Ethiopia and the upstream countries bound by moral rather than legal obligation.

Pulitzer’s hydropower story echoed this gap. It described the GERD as a symbol of both empowerment and defiance, “a dam not only on water but on colonial memory.”

4. Voices from the Basin: Justice or Power?

At the community level, the question is not about treaties but about life.
During ARMACA’s participative call-in segment, a farmer named Ato Mulugeta from the Lake Tana side shared:

“We see the power lines over our heads, but our homes are still dark. If this dam is ours, why can’t we have light?”

His voice trembled with both pride and disillusionment. The hydropower project that was supposed to illuminate rural Ethiopia remains a distant promise for many.

Dr. Susanne Schmeier, an expert on transboundary water law, responded during the webinar:

“International water law is not about who has more power. It’s about balancing needs and ensuring that shared rivers promote shared growth. The GERD should be a tool for integration, not isolation.”

Her words drew applause from studio guests and social media users following the broadcast live on ARMACA’s Facebook page.
Comments flooded in:

“Let the Nile unite us, not divide us.”
“Cooperation must start from local communities.”

5. The Law and the Dam

The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) looms large over every legal debate.
As Pulitzer’s “Who Owns the Nile?” reported, “Ethiopians have paid a massive cost — in financial and political terms for something that isn’t necessarily going to work unless regional laws catch up.”

The dam’s legal ambiguity reflects the larger failure of the basin to establish a shared regulatory mechanism. Dr. Salman elaborated:

“There is no binding institution that governs the dam’s operation. We depend on political goodwill, which is fragile and fleeting.”

Ethiopia’s decision to proceed with GERD’s filling without a regional agreement was seen by Egypt as unilateral and by Ethiopians as long-overdue sovereignty.

Dr. Cascão reminded the audience that this legal paradox is not unique:

“Most transboundary basins in Africa are governed by soft law. But the Nile, because of its geopolitical weight, cannot afford to rely on soft commitments.”

6. Building a Basin of Trust

In Bahir Dar’s studio, the conversation turned emotional.
ARMACA’s host, journalist Muluwork Tadesse, posed a question that struck at the heart of the matter:

“Can laws make people trust each other? Or must people trust before they can make laws?”

Dr. Schmeier smiled at the camera feed and replied,

“It’s both. Trust builds institutions, and institutions protect trust. But the process must be inclusive, from Cairo to Tana, Khartoum to Juba.”

Her reflection captured the spirit of the program, the belief that radio, conversation, and community awareness are themselves part of the legal fabric of peace.

7. Reflections from the Field

After the broadcast, ARMACA field reporters gathered reflections from listeners in Amhara and beyond.

  • Selamawit, a teacher from Gonder, said:

“Before, I thought the Nile was just about Egypt and Ethiopia fighting. Now I see it’s about law and fairness, who gets to decide how we share what God gave us.”

  • Abdel Rahman, a merchant from Metema, near the Sudanese border, commented:

“We trade with Sudan daily. If water becomes war, trade will die. We need the law to protect our peace.”

These voices illustrate what the experts have long said: cooperation is not only about institutions, it’s about relationships.

8. Conclusion: The Law Beneath the Water

As the sun sets over the Blue Nile, its golden currents carry both promise and peril.
The legal and institutional frameworks that govern its flow remain fragile, shaped by power, history, and hope.

From the colonial treaties to the Cooperative Framework Agreement, the Nile has been a mirror of Africa’s struggle, between dependence and development, between sovereignty and solidarity.

And yet, as the ARMACA–Pulitzer partnership reminds us, every voice, from scholars to farmers, belongs in this conversation. The river is not owned. It is shared.

#Hashtags for Digital Publication

#WhoOwnsTheNile
#HydropowerJustice
#PulitzerCenter
#ARMACAStories
#ClimateAndCommunity
#VoicesForResilience
#LakeTanaVoices
#BlueNileDialogues
#EnergyJustice
#NileBasinInitiative
#PeaceThroughWater
#SharedRiversSharedFutures

Produced by:
Amhara Region Media and Art Charitable Association (ARMACA)
With Support from the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting