16 min

In rural Ethiopia, the silence surrounding infertility can be as painful as the diagnosis itself. Women are often blamed, isolated and sometimes emotionally abused for failing to conceive. But when medical evidence reveals that infertility can also involve male factors, an old social narrative begins to crack.

By Ayele Addis Ambelu | News Analysis (ayeleradio@gmail.com) : Based on a true story

The accusation rarely arrives as a question. It comes as a whisper from a neighbor. A joke from a relative. A warning from an elder. Sometimes, it arrives in the silence of a husband who has stopped explaining himself.

For Kale, a 35-year-old woman living in rural Ethiopia, the absence of a child slowly became the presence that dominated her entire life. Every wedding she attended reminded her of what she did not have. Every pregnancy announcement reopened the wound. At family gatherings, questions about motherhood became increasingly difficult to answer.

“When will you have a child?”

It sounds harmless. For a woman who has spent years trying to conceive, it can feel like a verdict.

Kale’s experience reflects a much larger problem: infertility is not simply a medical condition. In communities where motherhood is closely tied to womanhood, infertility can become a social identity imposed on women, one that can strip away dignity, belonging and even security within their own homes.

But then came a discovery that changed the story. A mobile health clinic reached the community. For the first time, Amina’s husband was also examined.

The results challenged an assumption that had shaped years of blame: the problem was not necessarily hers. The medical evidence pointed toward a male-factor fertility problem.

Suddenly, the question changed. It was no longer simply, “Why can’t she have a child?” It became: “Why did everyone assume the woman was responsible?”

Shewit Anhna, Infertility Social injustice Awareness creator Photo by DERAJEW ESSA, MUHAMMED (Camera Person/ Video Journalist) ; Africa News Channel

A diagnosis that exposes a deeper social disease

Infertility is a medical issue, but the consequences are often social, economic and emotional.

The World Health Organization defines infertility as the inability to achieve pregnancy after 12 months or more of regular unprotected sexual intercourse. WHO estimates that infertility affects approximately one in six people globally at some point in their reproductive lives.

Yet the medical definition tells only part of the story.

In communities where having children is considered an essential part of marriage, infertility can carry a burden far beyond the clinic. A woman may be blamed for something she did not cause. She may be pressured to seek traditional remedies. She may spend scarce household income pursuing treatments without her partner being evaluated. She may face pressure for divorce or remarriage. And in the most damaging cases, she may experience emotional, physical or economic abuse. The tragedy is compounded by a basic misunderstanding:

Infertility is not exclusively a woman’s problem.

Male factors contribute substantially to infertility, either alone or together with female factors. Yet social attitudes can turn the woman into the first and sometimes only, person investigated. That is where medicine collides with culture. And culture can be difficult to diagnose.

The woman who carried a diagnosis that was never hers

For years, Kale carried the weight of an unanswered question. Why had she not become pregnant? Instead of receiving a shared medical investigation, she experienced what many women in similar circumstances encounter: suspicion, judgment and isolation. Her worth became entangled with her ability to give birth.

The more time passed, the more difficult ordinary life became. She began withdrawing from social occasions. Conversations about children became painful. The emotional distance inside her marriage deepened. This is one of the hidden costs of infertility.

The suffering is often invisible because there may be no physical symptom for a neighbor to see. There is no cast around a broken heart. No bandage for humiliation. No laboratory test that measures the damage caused by years of being told directly or indirectly that you are less of a woman because you have not become a mother.

The silence inside the marriage

Infertility can expose another uncomfortable reality: reproductive decisions are rarely controlled equally by women and men. In many rural communities, women may have less power to insist that their husbands undergo medical testing. A woman can be willing to visit a health facility while her husband refuses. She can accept examination while he considers testing an attack on his masculinity.

And when male infertility is associated with ideas about virility, admitting a fertility problem can become psychologically and socially difficult for men. This creates a dangerous cycle. The man avoids testing.
The woman carries the blame. The family reinforces the blame. The couple delays appropriate treatment.
Meanwhile, years pass.

Photo by DERAJEW ESSA, MUHAMMED (Camera Person/ Video Journalist) ; Africa News Channel, Shewit Anhna, Infertility Social injustice Awareness creator

When science enters the conversation

The mobile clinic did something deceptively simple. It treated fertility as a couple’s health issue, rather than a woman’s failure. That shift matters. When both partners are evaluated, medical professionals can identify possible causes, explain treatment options and help couples make informed decisions.

But medical access remains a major challenge, particularly for rural communities. Specialized infertility services can be concentrated in urban areas. Diagnostic tests may be expensive. Transportation can become an obstacle. Treatment may require repeated visits.

For low-income families, infertility care can compete with food, school fees, housing and other immediate needs. And when health information is scarce, misinformation fills the vacuum.

Traditional explanations may attribute infertility to curses, punishment, infidelity or spiritual causes. Such beliefs can coexist with medical care, but when they replace appropriate diagnosis, couples may lose valuable time.

From stigma to solidarity

Kale’s story does not end with a medical result. It begins there. The discovery that male factors could contribute to infertility forced her to reconsider years of self-blame. But perhaps more importantly, it gave her something that stigma had taken away: a voice.

She began speaking with other women experiencing similar struggles. What started as conversations became a support circle. Women who had previously suffered privately began sharing experiences.

Some discovered that they were not alone. Others learned that infertility could have multiple causes and that medical evaluation should involve both partners. The circle became more than a place to discuss pregnancy.

It became a space to discuss dignity. That distinction is crucial. The objective should not be to tell women that their value lies somewhere else while continuing to define them primarily through motherhood.

It should be to challenge the assumption that a woman’s worth is determined by whether she gives birth.

The economic price of stigma

Infertility can also become an economic burden. Families may spend money on repeated consultations, medicines, laboratory investigations and travel to distant hospitals. Some couples move between biomedical treatment and traditional practices, sometimes spending money on both.

Without adequate counselling, expectations can become unrealistic. The fertility industry itself can create another vulnerability: desperate couples may be susceptible to unproven treatments and financial exploitation.

This makes medical literacy particularly important. People need clear information about: when infertility should be investigated; why both partners should be assessed; what diagnostic tests can and cannot establish; which treatments are evidence-based; how much treatment may cost; where appropriate services are available; and what alternatives exist when pregnancy cannot be achieved.

Knowledge cannot guarantee a pregnancy. But it can prevent unnecessary blame.

The missing conversation: men

If Ethiopia wants to confront infertility stigma, one group cannot remain outside the conversation: men. Men need to hear that fertility testing does not determine masculinity. A sperm analysis is a medical test not a measurement of a man’s dignity. That message may sound simple, but changing attitudes requires trusted voices.

Health workers can help. Religious and community leaders can help. Journalists can help. Men who are willing to speak publicly about fertility challenges can help break the assumption that reproductive difficulties belong only to women. And couples need private, respectful counselling where neither partner becomes the target of blame.

What communities can do

The solution is not one clinic, one campaign or one support group. It requires several changes at once.

First, fertility education must reach rural communities. Mobile clinics and community health workers can bring basic reproductive-health information closer to people who cannot easily reach specialized facilities.

Second, infertility services should adopt a couple-centred approach. Health systems should encourage the assessment of both partners rather than allowing gender stereotypes to determine who gets tested.

Third, stigma must be treated as a public-health issue. Community conversations can challenge myths that infertility is evidence of punishment, moral failure or female inadequacy.

Fourth, mental and social support should become part of infertility care. A diagnosis does not exist in isolation from the person’s family, marriage and community.

Fifth, women need stronger social and economic agency. A woman’s ability to make health decisions should not depend entirely on whether she has produced a child.

And finally, men must be brought into reproductive-health conversations as partners—not merely as observers.

The bigger question

Kale’s experience ultimately raises a question much larger than infertility. What happens when a society measures a woman’s value through something her body may not be able to control? The answer can be devastating. A woman can become isolated inside her own marriage. She can lose social standing. She can become financially vulnerable. She can internalize blame. And perhaps most painfully, she can begin to believe the accusations around her. But the opposite is also possible.

Information can replace suspicion. Medical evidence can challenge myth. Couples can replace blame with shared responsibility. Communities can replace ridicule with solidarity. And women can begin to reclaim identities that were never supposed to depend on motherhood alone.

Beyond the silent cradles

The image of an empty cradle carries enormous emotional power in communities where children symbolize family, continuity and social belonging. But an empty cradle does not mean an empty life. That may be the most important lesson emerging from Amina’s journey.

Her story is not simply about a woman who struggled to conceive. It is about what happens when society decides who is responsible before medicine has even asked the right questions. The mobile clinic did more than provide a medical service. It disrupted a narrative.

It showed that infertility can involve men, women or both. It demonstrated the importance of shared diagnosis. And for Amina, it opened a path from private shame toward collective action. Her support circle now represents something larger than fertility.

It represents a different way of understanding women’s lives. A future in which a woman is not introduced first by whether she has children. A future in which a man’s fertility can be discussed without questioning his masculinity.

A future in which couples seek medical answers together. And a future in which communities understand that compassion is not a cure for infertility but it can prevent infertility from becoming a life sentence of shame.

The silent cradles may remain empty for some families. But the silence around them does not have to remain.